Water Walking Potion
Rare
53
Candy Cane
Common
28
Golden Leaf
Legendary
26
Goldenrod Flower
Legendary
11
Snowflake Potion
Uncommon
7
Dim Sum
Common
6
Heart Potion
Uncommon
4.5
Sugar Skull Potion
Ultra Rare
4
Christmas Pudding Pup Bait
Ultra Rare
4
Levitation Potion
Ultra Rare
3
Teleportation Potion
Uncommon
2.5
Chocolate Egg
Common
2.5
Chocolate
Common
2
Fly-A-Pet Potion (Forever)
Legendary
2
Broken Egg
Legendary
2
Super Age-Up Potion
Legendary
2